THE MONKEES PASSED ON “DIFFERENT DRUM.” WHEN THE STONE PONEYS RECORDED IT, LINDA RONSTADT WAS THE ONLY MEMBER OF THE GROUP ALLOWED TO PLAY ON THE HIT — AND THE SONG THAT SAVED THEIR CAREER ALSO HELPED PULL THE BAND APART. By 1967, Linda Ronstadt had already left Arizona for Los Angeles and formed the Stone Poneys with Bobby Kimmel and Kenny Edwards. Their first Capitol album had failed commercially, leaving the trio without the breakthrough they had expected. Then they found a song written by Michael Nesmith. “Different Drum” had been written before Nesmith became famous with the Monkees, and he later tried to bring it into that group’s orbit, only to have the material rejected by the people controlling much of the Monkees’ recording decisions. The song eventually reached the Stone Poneys, who heard the potential immediately. But the recording session changed more than the arrangement. The Stone Poneys had imagined the song as a relatively simple acoustic performance. Producer Nick Venet instead brought in outside session musicians, added strings and harpsichord, and built a more polished folk-pop arrangement around Ronstadt’s voice. Ronstadt was the only Stone Poneys member who actually performed on the released recording. Even Ronstadt was uneasy with the result. She later remembered feeling unprepared for the new arrangement and dissatisfied with aspects of her own vocal, yet listeners heard something else entirely. Released in 1967, “Different Drum” reached No. 13 on the Billboard Hot 100, giving Ronstadt her first national hit. The single was credited to the Stone Poneys but prominently identified her, and Capitol increasingly began treating Ronstadt as the act’s obvious focal point. That success created a problem the first album never had. The hit opened doors for Ronstadt while widening the distance inside the trio. The label wanted more of the voice that had sold the record, Ronstadt’s musical interests were moving beyond Bobby Kimmel’s material, and the Stone Poneys gradually became less a three-person identity than a vehicle built around their singer. By the end of 1968, the group was finished. Ronstadt stayed with Capitol and moved into a solo career that would eventually make her one of the dominant American singers of the 1970s. The striking part is that her first real hit did not arrive because a band finally found its perfect collective sound. It arrived when the studio temporarily removed the band from its own record — and discovered that the woman standing at the microphone could carry the song by herself.
“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” THE MONKEES PASSED ON “DIFFERENT DRUM.” THE STONE…