“THREE CHORDS AND THE TRUTH.” HARLAN HOWARD REDUCED COUNTRY MUSIC TO FIVE WORDS — THEN SPENT MORE THAN FORTY YEARS PROVING THEM WITH OTHER PEOPLE’S VOICES. Harlan Howard never needed complicated language to explain what he believed a country song should do. He had grown up listening to Ernest Tubb on the Grand Ole Opry, sometimes writing down lyrics as they came through the radio. If his hand fell behind, he would invent the missing lines himself. Long before Nashville knew his name, Howard was already learning that a song had to tell its story quickly and clearly. Eventually he gave that instinct a definition: “Three chords and the truth.” By the time Howard reached Nashville in 1960, the formula was already working. Charlie Walker had taken “Pick Me Up on Your Way Down” to No. 2. Ray Price had done the same with “Heartaches by the Number,” while Guy Mitchell’s pop version went to No. 1. Then the songs began appearing everywhere. Howard and Hank Cochran wrote “I Fall to Pieces,” which Patsy Cline initially resisted recording with Owen Bradley’s polished Nashville Sound arrangement. Released in 1961, it eventually became her first No. 1 country single. Howard wrote “Busted.” Ray Charles carried it to No. 4 on the pop chart in 1963. He co-wrote “I’ve Got a Tiger by the Tail” with Buck Owens, helping produce another defining Bakersfield hit. Then came artists and generations that had not even entered the business when Howard started: The Judds recorded “Why Not Me.” Patty Loveless took “Blame It on Your Heart” to No. 1 in 1993. Howard made records himself, but he never seriously chased stardom as a performer. The songs were the career. Nashville eventually called him “Mr. Songwriter” and the “dean” of its professional writers. By the time he died in 2002, Howard had written thousands of songs and more than 100 of his compositions had reached the country Top 10. But there is a later detail that says more about their durability. In 2023, more than twenty years after Howard’s death, Willie Nelson recorded an entire album of Harlan Howard songs, I Don’t Know a Thing About Love. The songwriter had been gone for two decades. Other voices were still finding new things to say with his words.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” “THREE CHORDS AND THE TRUTH.” HARLAN HOWARD REDUCED…

ATLANTIC RECORDS WANTED DANNY SHIRLEY ALONE. HE REFUSED—AND THE BAND HE INSISTED ON BRINGING WITH HIM WENT DOUBLE PLATINUM AS CONFEDERATE RAILROAD. Before Confederate Railroad had a name, Danny Shirley and the musicians around him had already spent years in the harder edges of country music. Shirley had worked with David Allan Coe, while members of the group played behind artists including Coe and Johnny Paycheck. By the late 1980s, they were playing Nashville clubs together as a house band, mixing country with Southern rock, honky-tonk and a deliberately rough image far removed from Nashville polish. Then Atlantic Records became interested. The label initially considered signing Shirley as a solo artist. Shirley pushed back. Nashville already had plenty of solo singers, he argued, and the chemistry came from the musicians playing together. Atlantic agreed. Confederate Railroad signed with the label, and their self-titled debut arrived in 1992. The gamble worked quickly. “Jesus and Mama” reached the country Top 5. “Queen of Memphis” climbed to No. 2, while “Trashy Women” became the song most closely associated with the band. The album eventually went double platinum, and the Academy of Country Music named Confederate Railroad Top New Vocal Group. They followed with Notorious and another run of hits, including “Daddy Never Was the Cadillac Kind,” proving the first album had not simply been a novelty-driven accident. Shirley could have entered Nashville with his own name on the record sleeve. Instead, he insisted on bringing the people who had already been standing behind him. Years later, the name that survived from that decision was not Danny Shirley. It was Confederate Railroad.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” ATLANTIC RECORDS WANTED DANNY SHIRLEY AS A SOLO…

ACHY BREAKY HEART” MADE BILLY RAY CYRUS A STAR ALMOST OVERNIGHT. IT ALSO BECAME SO BIG THAT FOR YEARS, THE SONG WAS HARDER TO ESCAPE THAN THE MAN WHO SANG IT. THEN 27 YEARS LATER, “OLD TOWN ROAD” PUT HIM BACK INSIDE THE BIGGEST HIT IN AMERICA. Billy Ray Cyrus arrived nationally in 1992 with almost no gradual climb. “Achy Breaky Heart” went to No. 1 on the country chart, while his debut album *Some Gave All* exploded beyond country music. It spent 17 consecutive weeks atop the Billboard 200 and became the best-selling album in America that year. Cyrus was suddenly everywhere. So was the backlash. The song’s line dance, Cyrus’ mullet and the enormous crossover attention turned him into a pop-culture phenomenon, but they also reduced a much broader country career to one image. He kept recording and scoring country hits, including “Could’ve Been Me,” “In the Heart of a Woman” and “Busy Man,” yet nothing could compete with the shadow of those first months. As the 1990s ended, country radio moved on. Then came 2019. A 20-year-old rapper named Lil Nas X had created “Old Town Road,” a short country-trap song that went viral through TikTok. After Billboard removed the original recording from its Hot Country Songs chart, Billy Ray Cyrus joined the remix. It was an unlikely pairing: a young internet-born rapper at the beginning of his career and a country singer still widely associated with a novelty-sized hit from 1992. The remix became enormous. “Old Town Road” spent a then-record 19 weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100. For Cyrus, it ended a gap of **26 years and eight months** between Hot 100 Top 10 appearances. It also introduced him to listeners who had not been born when “Achy Breaky Heart” was released. The collaboration earned Grammy nominations for Record of the Year and won Best Pop Duo/Group Performance and Best Music Video. Cyrus had spent decades being identified with the record that made him famous. Then the streaming generation attached his name to another cultural phenomenon entirely. This time, he was not the young star standing in the center of it. He was the veteran standing beside a 20-year-old newcomer while country, rap and the internet collided around them.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” “ACHY BREAKY HEART” MADE BILLY RAY CYRUS FAMOUS…

JEFF BATES HAD THE VOICE TO SING COUNTRY MUSIC. METH TOOK HIM SOMEWHERE ELSE FIRST — INTO CRIME, JAIL AND A LIFE THAT NEARLY COLLAPSED BEFORE NASHVILLE EVER KNEW HIS NAME. Jeff Bates grew up in Mississippi with a deep baritone shaped by singers like Conway Twitty, Elvis Presley and Joe Cocker. By the 1990s, he was trying to build a music career, eventually making his way toward Nashville. But while the opportunity moved slowly, his methamphetamine addiction grew worse. Music stopped being the center of his life. Drugs became it. The addiction led Bates into crime and eventually jail. Instead of reaching Nashville as another promising Southern singer, he reached a point where the career he wanted mattered less than whether he could rebuild his life at all. Recovery came first. Bates got sober and began putting the pieces back together. Then music returned. By late 2002, only a few years removed from the darkest period of his addiction, RCA Nashville signed him to a major-label deal. *Rainbow Man* arrived in 2003. Its breakthrough single, “The Love Song,” climbed to No. 8 on Billboard’s country chart. The voice Bates had nearly thrown away was suddenly coming through country radio nationwide. “I Wanna Make You Cry” followed, and “Long, Slow Kisses” later reached No. 17. Bates never became a stadium-level star, but his past gave some of his later material a weight chart numbers could not provide. “One Second Chance,” in particular, landed differently coming from a man who had needed one himself. He also never hid the musical influence behind that deep voice. In 2014, Bates released *Me & Conway*, a tribute connecting him directly to Conway Twitty, one of the singers listeners had compared him to for years. But by then, Bates had another reason to keep telling his own story. He began speaking openly about addiction and recovery, including visits to prisons and treatment settings where the people listening were much closer to the life he had once lived than to the country charts he later reached. For them, “The Love Song” reaching No. 8 was not necessarily the most important number in Jeff Bates’ story. The years sober afterward were.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” JEFF BATES HAD THE VOICE TO SING COUNTRY…

BUDDY JEWELL SANG MORE THAN 4,000 DEMOS SO OTHER COUNTRY SINGERS COULD FIND THEIR NEXT HIT. THEN, AFTER NEARLY A DECADE IN NASHVILLE WITHOUT A RECORD DEAL, AMERICA FINALLY VOTED FOR THE MAN BEHIND THE VOICE. Buddy Jewell came to Nashville in 1993 expecting to become a recording artist. Nashville found another use for him. By the mid-1990s, Jewell was working steadily as a demo singer. Songwriters needed professional recordings to pitch their material to artists and labels, and Jewell had the kind of country voice that could make an unfinished song sound ready for radio. The work paid bills. It also kept him anonymous. Over the years, Jewell estimated that he sang more than 4,000 demos. Some of those songs eventually found their way to major artists, including George Strait, Clay Walker and Trace Adkins. Jewell kept watching songs leave the demo room and build careers for somebody else. His own deal never came. Nearly ten years after arriving in Nashville, he was married, raising a family and still working behind the scenes when a new television competition called *Nashville Star* began looking for contestants. Jewell auditioned. He was 41 years old. That mattered in a business increasingly interested in finding young artists it could build for the future. Jewell was competing not only against other singers, but against the years Nashville had already spent declining to make him one of its stars. Then the audience started voting. Week after week, Jewell survived. On May 3, 2003, he reached the finale against John Arthur Martinez and a 19-year-old Miranda Lambert. Jewell won. He received roughly 65 percent of the nationwide vote, finishing more than two million votes ahead of Lambert. The machinery that had refused to move for nearly a decade suddenly moved very quickly. Columbia Records Nashville signed him. Clint Black produced his debut album, and only weeks after the *Nashville Star* finale, *Buddy Jewell* was released. It entered Billboard’s Top Country Albums chart at No. 1. “Help Pour Out the Rain (Lacey’s Song),” inspired by a conversation with his daughter, became a Top 5 country hit. “Sweet Southern Comfort” followed into the Top 10. For years, Jewell had stood behind a studio microphone trying to make somebody else’s song convincing enough for a star to record. In 2003, the microphone stayed exactly where it had always been. The name printed on the record was what finally changed.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” BUDDY JEWELL SANG MORE THAN 4,000 DEMOS SO…

DAVID LEE MURPHY LOST HIS PLACE ON COUNTRY RADIO—THEN WROTE NO. 1 HITS FOR OTHER STARS BEFORE RETURNING 23 YEARS LATER WITH ONE OF HIS OWN. David Lee Murphy arrived in Nashville in 1983, carrying songs and hoping to become a recording artist. Producer Tony Brown heard him performing in a club two years later. Brown recognized the talent, but no contract followed. Murphy remained in Nashville, writing, playing showcases and waiting nearly a decade for the opportunity to catch up with the first impression. MCA finally signed him, and Out with a Bang arrived in 1994. “Party Crowd” became a major hit. Then “Dust on the Bottle,” a song Murphy wrote himself, reached No. 1 in October 1995. Its story about an old bottle of homemade wine turned him into one of the most recognizable new voices of the decade. More hits followed, including “Every Time I Get Around You” and “The Road You Leave Behind.” But by the end of the 1990s, Murphy’s singles had begun disappearing from the upper reaches of country radio. His third MCA album produced no major hit, and the record deal ended. He returned with Tryin’ to Get There in 2004. “Loco” briefly carried his voice back onto the chart, but the album did not rebuild the commercial run he had known a decade earlier. Murphy then stepped away from recording under his own name. The songs did not stop. Murphy moved deeper into writing rooms, creating material for artists who were now occupying the radio space he had left behind. Kenny Chesney recorded “Living in Fast Forward,” followed by songs including “Live a Little,” “Pirate Flag,” “’Til It’s Gone” and “Here and Now.” Jason Aldean took “Big Green Tractor” and “The Only Way I Know” to No. 1. Jake Owen recorded “Anywhere with You.” Thompson Square turned “Are You Gonna Kiss Me or Not” into a chart-topper and a Grammy-nominated song. His writing also reached Blake Shelton, Gary Allan, Justin Moore, Kip Moore, Eli Young Band, Blackberry Smoke and other artists across several generations of country music. By then, Murphy’s voice was no longer required for one of his ideas to travel. Kenny Chesney eventually pulled him back toward the microphone. The two had spent years writing together, and Chesney encouraged Murphy to make another album. They co-produced No Zip Code, Murphy’s first studio record in fourteen years. Its lead single, “Everything’s Gonna Be Alright,” paired Murphy with Chesney. Released at the end of 2017, it rose to No. 1 on the country airplay chart in 2018—twenty-three years after “Dust on the Bottle” had given Murphy his first chart-topper as an artist. The song also earned them the CMA Award for Musical Event of the Year. Murphy’s return was not the usual comeback of an artist rediscovered after years of silence. He had never disappeared from Nashville. He had simply moved to the side of the recording studio where the public could not see him. By the time he stepped forward again, several of the singers who had carried his songs were standing among country music’s largest stars. Murphy no longer needed another hit to prove that he belonged there. Still, in 2018, the songwriter who had spent years watching other voices take his words to No. 1 heard his own voice coming through the radio again.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” DAVID LEE MURPHY LOST HIS PLACE ON COUNTRY…

IRA LOUVIN DIED IN A CAR CRASH IN 1965. CHARLIE LOUVIN LIVED LONG ENOUGH TO HEAR THEIR BROTHER-HARMONY BECOME HOLY GROUND FOR COUNTRY MUSIC. Before the wreck, The Louvin Brothers sounded like two men raised close enough to breathe the same note. Ira and Charlie Louvin came out of Alabama gospel, shaped-note singing, Baptist warning songs, and the old close-harmony tradition of brother acts. Ira had the high, cutting tenor. Charlie held the lower part. Together, they could make a hymn sound like judgment and a country song sound like a confession. By the 1950s, they were Grand Ole Opry regulars. “When I Stop Dreaming,” “I Don’t Believe You’ve Met My Baby,” “Cash on the Barrelhead,” and later the strange fire of *Satan Is Real* gave them a place no ordinary duo could hold. Their harmonies were beautiful, but the life behind them was not clean. Ira was brilliant and difficult. Drinking, rage, broken marriages, and violence followed him. Charlie finally grew tired of trying to hold the act together. In 1963, the brothers split. Charlie went solo. Ira tried to keep going too. In 1965, he had just completed his only solo album, *The Unforgettable Ira Louvin*. Three months later, on June 20, he and his fourth wife, Anne, died in a car crash in Missouri. The Louvin Brothers were already over by then. But after Ira’s death, the ending changed. It was no longer just a duo that broke apart. It became a harmony cut in half before country music fully understood what it had lost. Charlie kept singing for decades. The brother beside him never came back.

“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” IRA LOUVIN DIED IN A MISSOURI CAR CRASH…

You Missed

MARTY STUART WAS 13 WHEN HE GOT OFF A GREYHOUND BUS IN NASHVILLE. THE NEXT DAY HE CLIMBED ON LESTER FLATT’S TOUR BUS. BY THE END OF THE WEEKEND, HE HAD A JOB PLAYING WITH A COUNTRY MUSIC LEGEND. On August 3, 1972, Marty Stuart stepped off a bus in downtown Nashville from Mississippi. He was thirteen years old. Stuart had already learned guitar and mandolin and played with the Sullivan Family, but Nashville was still something he knew mostly from records and Grand Ole Opry broadcasts. Early that morning, he walked to the Ryman Auditorium before the city had fully come alive. Bluegrass musician Roland White soon picked him up in a 1965 Chevrolet Impala. The next day, White took Stuart to Lester Flatt’s tour bus in Hendersonville. They headed to a bluegrass festival in Delaware, where the teenager was given a chance to play with Flatt’s band. Flatt heard enough. By the end of the weekend, he wanted Stuart in the Nashville Grass permanently. After arrangements were made with his parents, Stuart joined the road at an age when most musicians were still learning songs in bedrooms and school gyms. A week later, he made his first appearance on the Grand Ole Opry. Stuart stayed with Flatt through most of the 1970s. The education happened night after night: long bus rides, festival stages, dressing rooms, radio appearances and hours beside musicians who had helped build bluegrass and country before he was born. When Flatt’s health declined and the band ended, Stuart moved on. He worked with Doc Watson and other musicians, then joined Johnny Cash’s band in 1980. Only later did he build a solo career of his own. “Crying, Waiting, Hoping,” “Hillbilly Rock,” “Tempted,” and his recordings with Travis Tritt helped turn Stuart from respected sideman into a country star. In 1992, he became a member of the Grand Ole Opry. In 2020, he was elected to the Country Music Hall of Fame. But those early years with Flatt left another mark. Stuart began saving the instruments, photographs, stage clothes and personal objects that passed through the country world around him. What started as a young musician holding onto pieces of his heroes eventually grew into one of the most important private collections of country-music history. The road job Lester Flatt gave him taught Stuart how to play the music. It also taught him how quickly the people and objects that made it could disappear.

JOE DIFFIE HAD BEEN OFF THE CENTER OF COUNTRY RADIO FOR YEARS. THEN JASON ALDEAN RELEASED A SONG THAT HAD AN ENTIRE NEW GENERATION CHANTING HIS NAME. In 1994, Joe Diffie was near the height of his career. “Third Rock from the Sun” reached No. 1. Then “Pickup Man” followed and stayed there four weeks. Jason Aldean was still a high-school junior in Georgia, listening to Diffie and playing songs from that era before his own career existed. Aldean later remembered attending a Macon festival where roughly 5,000 people gathered for Diffie while only a few hundred watched a young Kenny Chesney on another stage. Almost two decades passed. By 2012, Aldean had become one of country music’s biggest stars. Songwriters Thomas Rhett, Luke Laird and Barry Dean were working on another song when the session changed direction. They built a track around 1990s nostalgia, filling it with references to Diffie records including “Pickup Man,” “John Deere Green,” “Third Rock from the Sun” and “Honky Tonk Attitude.” They called it “1994.” Aldean heard the demo while songs were being pitched for him and asked to hear it again. Soon afterward, he recorded it for Night Train. It became the album’s third single in March 2013. Diffie had nothing to do with making the record. Then he heard what they had done. His name had become the chant at the center of the song. Diffie said he was initially stunned, then realized what it meant: thousands of younger Aldean fans would suddenly be shouting the name of a singer whose biggest records had been released when many of them were children—or not yet born. The effect followed him off the radio. Diffie later said younger people began showing up at his concerts wanting to find out who the man from “1994” actually was. What surprised him even more was that many had gone backward into his catalog and learned the older songs. He called the attention a “shot in the arm.” Aldean had grown up playing Joe Diffie songs in Georgia clubs. Years later, some of Aldean’s own fans discovered those same records by moving in the opposite direction—starting with Jason Aldean and working their way back to Joe.

LITTLE JIMMY DICKENS STOOD 4’11”. TRACE ADKINS STOOD 6’6″. SO WHEN DICKENS CAME OUT TO INVITE HIM INTO THE GRAND OLE OPRY, HE BROUGHT A STEPLADDER. By 2003, Trace Adkins was no longer the unknown Louisiana singer who had arrived in Nashville a decade earlier. He had built a run of country hits, and the Grand Ole Opry had been part of that journey since his debut there on November 23, 1996. Then came June 14, 2003. Adkins had finished his set at the Opry and was preparing to leave the stage when Little Jimmy Dickens appeared in a bright blue Nudie suit. He was carrying a stepladder. Dickens was only 4’11”. Adkins towered over him at 6’6″. So Dickens set down the ladder, climbed the steps until the two men were nearly eye-to-eye, and asked Adkins how badly he wanted to become part of the Grand Ole Opry family. The joke landed immediately. But the invitation underneath it was real. Adkins accepted, and when the time came for his formal induction, he was allowed to choose the Opry member he wanted to welcome him into the family. He chose Ronnie Milsap, one of his musical heroes. On August 23, 2003, Milsap officially inducted Trace Adkins into the Grand Ole Opry. Twenty years later, Adkins returned to the same stage to celebrate the anniversary. This time the significance had moved beyond the joke that began it. He said Opry membership had affected the way he conducted himself because he felt responsible for representing the institution. And the tradition kept moving forward. In 2018, Adkins walked onto that stage unexpectedly during Dustin Lynch’s set and asked another country singer to join the Opry family. Little Jimmy Dickens had once come out to get Trace Adkins. Fifteen years later, Trace was the man being sent out to get the next one