KEITH WHITLEY AND EARL THOMAS CONLEY RECORDED “BROTHERLY LOVE” IN 1987. IT SAT UNRELEASED FOR FOUR YEARS. BY THE TIME IT BECAME A NO. 2 HIT, WHITLEY HAD BEEN DEAD FOR MORE THAN TWO YEARS. In 1987, Keith Whitley and Earl Thomas Conley were two of country music’s most recognizable voices. Conley was deep into the extraordinary run that would give him 18 No. 1 hits. Whitley was still climbing, only a year away from the breakthrough stretch that produced “Don’t Close Your Eyes,” “When You Say Nothing at All” and “I’m No Stranger to the Rain.” That year, they recorded “Brotherly Love,” written by Tim Nichols and Jimmy Alan Stewart. The song was built around two brothers who fight, compete and irritate each other, but remain bound by something stronger underneath. Then the recording disappeared into the vault. It was not released as a single. It did not appear on either man’s current album. On May 9, 1989, Whitley died from alcohol poisoning at 34. His career did not immediately stop with his death. RCA still had unreleased material, and records including “I Wonder Do You Think of Me” and “I’m Over You” became posthumous hits. Then, in 1991, someone went back to the duet with Conley. “Brotherly Love” appeared on Whitley’s posthumous *Kentucky Bluebird* and Conley’s *Yours Truly*. RCA released it as a single that August. Four years after the two men had stood in the studio together, their voices finally reached country radio side by side. The record climbed to No. 2 on Billboard’s country chart, spending 20 weeks on the chart. It later earned a Grammy nomination for Best Country Collaboration with Vocals. It also became the final Top 10 country hit for both singers. For Whitley, there could never be another session. For Conley, the result was different. He lived nearly three more decades, but country radio was changing, and none of his later singles returned him to the Top 10. So one recording from 1987 quietly became a dividing line neither man could have recognized when they made it. They walked into the studio with separate careers still moving forward. Country radio finally brought their voices together after one of those careers had already ended.
“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” KEITH WHITLEY AND EARL THOMAS CONLEY RECORDED “BROTHERLY…